This is based on a set of suggestions from Noah, with the following
changes made:
- The set of databases created in the tests are now prefixed with
"regression" to not trigger any warnings with name restrictions when
compiling the code with -DENFORCE_REGRESSION_TEST_NAME_RESTRICTIONS, and
now only the first name checks after the Windows case of double quotes
mixed with backslashes.
- Fix an issue with EXTRA_REGRESS_OPTS, which were not processed in a
way consistent with 027_stream_regress.pl (missing space between the
option string and pg_regress). This got introduced in 7dd3ee5.
- Add a check on the exit code of the pg_regress command, to catch
failures after running the regression tests.
Reviewed-by: Noah Misch
Discussion: https://postgr.es/m/YoHhWD5vQzb2mmiF@paquier.xyz
This commit addresses the following issues in the TAP tests of
pg_upgrade, introduced in 322becb:
- Remove --port and --host for commands that already rely on a node's
environment PGHOST and PGPORT.
- Switch from run_log() to command_ok(), as all the commands executed in
the tests should succeed.
- Change EXTRA_REGRESS_OPTS to make it count as a shell fragment (fixing
s/OPT/OPTS on a way), to be compatible with the various Makefiles using
it as well as 027_stream_regress.pl in the recovery tests. The command
built for the execution the pg_regress command is reformatted, while on
it, to map with the recovery test doing the same thing (we should
refactor and consolidate that in the future, perhaps).
- Re-add the test for database names stressing the behavior of
backslashes with double quotes, mostly here for Windows.
Tests doable with the upgrade across different major versions still work
the same way.
Reported-by: Noah Misch
Discussion: https://postgr.es/m/20220502042718.GB1565149@rfd.leadboat.com
This commit includes a set of improvements to help with the debugging of
failures in these new TAP tests:
- Instead of a plain diff command to compare the dumps generated, use
File::Compare::compare for the same effect. diff is still used to
provide more context in the event of an error.
- Log the contents of regression.diffs if the pg_regress command fails.
- Unify the format of the logs generated, getting inspiration from the
style used in 027_stream_regress.pl.
wrasse is the only buildfarm member that has reported a failure until
now after the introduction of 322becb, complaining that the dumps
generated do not match, and I am lacking information to understand what
is going in this environment.
This simplifies a lot of code in the tests of pg_upgrade without
sacrificing its coverage:
- Removal of test.sh used for builds with make, that has accumulated
over the years tweaks for problems that are solved in a duplicated way
by the centralized TAP framework (initialization of the various
environment variables PG*, port selection).
- Removal of the code in MSVC to test pg_upgrade. This was roughly a
duplicate of test.sh adapted for Windows, with an extra footprint of
a pg_regress command and all the assumptions behind it.
Support for upgrades with older versions is changed, not removed.
test.sh was able to set up the regression database on the old instance
by launching itself the pg_regress command and a dependency to the
source tree of thd old cluster, with tweaks on the command arguments to
adapt across the versions used. This created a backward-compatibility
dependency with older pg_regress commands, and recent changes like
d1029bb have made that much more complicated.
Instead, this commit allows tests with older major versions by
specifying a path to a SQL dump (taken with pg_dumpall from the old
cluster's installation) that will be loaded into the old instance to
upgrade instead of running pg_regress, through an optional environment
variable called $olddump. This requires a second variable called
$oldinstall to point to the base path of the installation of the old
cluster. This method is more in line with the buildfarm client that
uses a set of static dumps to set up an old instance, so hopefully we
will be able to reuse what is introduced in this commit there. The last
step of the tests that checks for differences between the two dumps
taken still needs to be improved as it can fail, requiring a manual
lookup at the dumps. This is not different from the old way of testing
where things could fail at the last step.
Support for EXTRA_REGRESS_OPTS is kept. vcregress.pl in the MSVC
scripts still handles the test of pg_upgrade with its upgradecheck, and
bincheck is changed to skip pg_upgrade.
Author: Michael Paquier
Reviewed-by: Andrew Dunstan, Andres Freund, Rachel Heaton, Tom Lane,
Discussion: https://postgr.es/m/YJ8xTmLQkotVLpN5@paquier.xyz
Michael Paquier
Tom Lane