I'd not checked that this iteration of the test actually worked
with a bootstrap superuser not named 'postgres'. It didn't,
because the coercion rules for CASE caused us to try to cast
the 'postgres' literal to regrole. Mea culpa.
Per buildfarm (via Alexander Korotkov)
Discussion: https://postgr.es/m/CAPpHfdsV=iTvH6B858hnH1bLgewYH6cdTnO_eOOw9EOa8kehkA@mail.gmail.com
If an ACL recorded in pg_init_privs mentions a non-pinned role,
that reference must also be noted in pg_shdepend so that we know
that the role can't go away without removing the ACL reference.
Otherwise, DROP ROLE could succeed and leave dangling entries
behind, which is what's causing the recent upgrade-check failures
on buildfarm member copperhead.
This has been wrong since pg_init_privs was introduced, but it's
escaped notice because typical pg_init_privs entries would only
mention the bootstrap superuser (pinned) or at worst the owner
of the extension (who can't go away before the extension does).
We lack even a representation of such a role reference for
pg_shdepend. My first thought for a solution was entries listing
pg_init_privs in classid, but that doesn't work because then there's
noplace to put the granted-on object's classid. Rather than adding
a new column to pg_shdepend, let's add a new deptype code
SHARED_DEPENDENCY_INITACL. Much of the associated boilerplate
code can be cribbed from code for SHARED_DEPENDENCY_ACL.
A lot of the bulk of this patch just stems from the new need to pass
the object's owner ID to recordExtensionInitPriv, so that we can
consult it while updating pg_shdepend. While many callers have that
at hand already, a few places now need to fetch the owner ID of an
arbitrary privilege-bearing object. For that, we assume that there
is a catcache on the relevant catalog's OID column, which is an
assumption already made in ExecGrant_common so it seems okay here.
We do need an entirely new routine RemoveRoleFromInitPriv to perform
cleanup of pg_init_privs ACLs during DROP OWNED BY. It's analogous
to RemoveRoleFromObjectACL, but we can't share logic because that
function operates by building a command parsetree and invoking
existing GRANT/REVOKE infrastructure. There is of course no SQL
command that would update pg_init_privs entries when we're not in
process of creating their extension, so we need a routine that can
do the updates directly.
catversion bump because this changes the expected contents of
pg_shdepend. For the same reason, there's no hope of back-patching
this, even though it fixes a longstanding bug. Fortunately, the
case where it's a problem seems to be near nonexistent in the field.
If it weren't for the buildfarm breakage, I'd have been content to
leave this for v18.
Patch by me; thanks to Daniel Gustafsson for review and discussion.
Discussion: https://postgr.es/m/1745535.1712358659@sss.pgh.pa.us
Project policy is to not leave global objects behind after a regress
test run. This was found as a result of the development of a patch
to make pg_regress detect such leftovers automatically, which in the
end was withdrawn due to issues with parallel runs.
Discussion: https://postgr.es/m/E1phvk7-000VAH-7k@gemulon.postgresql.org
recordExtObjInitPriv and removeExtObjInitPriv were sloppy about
calling ReleaseSysCache. The cases cannot occur given current usage
in ALTER EXTENSION ADD/DROP, since we wouldn't get here for these
relkinds; but it seems wise to clean up better.
In passing, extend test logic in test_pg_dump to exercise the
dropped-column code paths here.
Since the case is unreachable at present, there seems no great
need to back-patch; hence fix HEAD only.
Kyotaro Horiguchi, with test case and comment adjustments by me
Discussion: https://postgr.es/m/20200417.151831.1153577605111650154.horikyota.ntt@gmail.com
In commit 6c268df, pg_init_privs was added to track the initial
privileges of catalog objects and extensions. Unfortunately, that
commit didn't include understanding of ALTER EXTENSION ADD/DROP, which
allows the objects associated with an extension to be changed after the
initial CREATE EXTENSION script has been run.
The result of this meant that ACLs for objects added through
ALTER EXTENSION ADD were not recorded into pg_init_privs and we would
end up including those ACLs in pg_dump when we shouldn't have.
This commit corrects that by making sure to have pg_init_privs updated
when ALTER EXTENSION ADD/DROP is run, recording the permissions as they
are at ALTER EXTENSION ADD time, and removing any if/when ALTER
EXTENSION DROP is called.
This issue was pointed out by Moshe Jacobson as commentary on bug #14456
(which was actually a bug about versions prior to 9.6 not handling
custom ACLs on extensions correctly, an issue now addressed with
pg_init_privs in 9.6).
Back-patch to 9.6 where pg_init_privs was introduced.
This TAP test suite will create a new cluster, populate it based on
the 'create_sql' values in the '%tests' hash, run all of the runs
defined in the '%pgdump_runs' hash, and then for each test in the
'%tests' hash, compare each run's output the the regular expression
defined for the test under the 'like' and 'unlike' functions, as
appropriate.
While this test suite covers a fair bit of ground (67% of pg_dump.c
and quite a bit of the other files in src/bin/pg_dump), there is
still quite a bit which remains to be added to provide better code
coverage. Still, this is quite a bit better than we had, and has
found a few bugs already (note that the CREATE TRANSFORM test is
commented out, as it is currently failing).
Idea for using the TAP system from Tom, though all of the code is mine.
Tom Lane
Daniel Gustafsson
Stephen Frost